Science Information

Hobbits and Lice


HOBBITS AND LICE:

In late 2004 the media was all agog with the small hominids found on Flores Island where I had written about artifacts showing sea travel technology must have existed. I had argued with many people about the issue and their argument had some merit in that we had no proof of a connection to humans or the nearby Mungo Man. However, once we found these creatures which some researchers even think could be part chimpanzee the issue became clearly in my favor. I think the divergence of human lice proven through DNA technology going back 1.18 to 1.8 million years ago is even more telling and I look forward to the further research on pubic lice that might prove hominids cross-breeding. Here is one source for further review.

"It was astonishing and exciting enough to have discovered a new - and wholly unexpected - hominid species last week. The discovery of the partial skeletons of three-foot tall "hobbits" on the Indonesian island of Flores would have been front page news however old they were. But what made them really extraordinary was their age. They weren't fossils. These were bones rotted to the consistency of blotting paper, less than 18,000 years old; and there are grounds for hoping that the creatures lived on into historical times. Some might even be alive in sufficiently remote island jungles today. The native legends about "Ebu Gogo" suggest that contact between Homo sapiens and Homo floresiensis took place within the last century on Flores.

The idea that our ancestors had contact with other human species is a profound and disturbing one. The whole term "human species" begs the question. If they are other species, can they really be what we mean by "human"? Human is a moral category as much as a biological one. That's why it is such a useful weapon word in the debates about abortion. To call someone or something human is generally meant as praise, and implies that they should be treated as we treat ourselves.

This interpretation of "humanity" is not, of course, a necessarily human trait. It's certainly not encoded in our genes. Most cultures, in most of history, have had no trouble in treating other human beings as domesticated animals or very much worse. But we, who speak English, call this process "dehumanisation".

The skeletal fragments, and the legends from local people, make this story far more vivid than the other evidence for human encounters with other humanoid species. That shouldn't obscure the fact that this is the second such story this autumn, and the first one is far more chilling.

The evidence there came from lice. As the parents of almost any school age girl will know, human lice are extraordinarily tenacious and well adapted to life on our scalps. They don't survive for more than a few hours away from human flesh.

The war between lice and their hosts has continued for billions of years - there are species of louse adapted to almost every sort of primate and many species of birds. In humans, they infest our head, our clothes, and our bodily hair. Curiously, the body lice are the same species as head lice - although they behave quite differently, living in clothes, and coming in to feed on skin once or twice a day. Head lice live in hair and feed more often.

But it turns out that DNA analysis shows there are two distinct sub-species of head lice in humans. All over the world, except in western North America, they are the same. But there is a population of lice along the Pacific coast of North America which have been evolving separately from the rest of the world for about 1.8m years. The only way to make sense of this is to assume that their separate development took place on Homo erectus, who also split off from our hominid ancestors about that time ago.

So how could these lice have reached their present, wholly human hosts? It seems to me that this could only have happened through some act of primal genocide when Homo erectus met Homo sapiens somewhere in eastern Siberia. Lice can only travel between living bodies, or very freshly dead ones. If the transmission had been from living bodies, we would expect the same pattern in bodily lice. It isn't there. Nor is there any trace of Homo erectus in our DNA. So the lice must have come from very fresh corpses and it is hard to suppose that they had died peacefully just before the intruders turned up.

The story of "Ebu Gogo" sounds more improving. According to local villagers, these creatures were around until about a century ago: three feet tall, hairy, and speechless, though they could imitate human speech, like parrots. The villagers tolerated them and even fed them, though they would only eat raw food, until they stole and ate a baby. They drove them from their cave with blazing bales of grass. Shortly thereafter, the villagers themselves moved off and western settlers arrived. The cave where the Ebu Gogo lived has not been found. But if it is - and scientists are looking - it might yield some extraordinary remains.

These wouldn't be technological. Perhaps the saddest aspect of the whole story is the slow loss of technology it implies. Ebu Gogo seems to have been a descendent of Homo erectus, also known as Java man, who reached the island about 840,000 years ago. This was almost certainly something that required boats, which seem a pretty human-level technology." (1)

Author of Diverse Druids Columnist for The ES Press Magazine Soon to be featured with Philip Gardiner


MORE RESOURCES:

Science Now

Science Takes 2 Hispanic Sisters To White House
Fox News
Print Email Share Comments Recommend Tweet Two Hispanic sisters from Presidio, Texas, have had their efforts and their inventiveness at designing rockets recognized by being invited to participate in the White House Science Fair, which is sponsored by ...
US lag in science, math a disaster in the makingCNN International
A marshmallow blaster and a blog give science a new lookWashington Post (blog)
Teen Wows at White House Science FairExaminer.com
Huffington Post -Science Now
all 1,217 news articles »


Voice of America (blog)

Life in Antarctic lake? It's everywhere else
Boston.com
By Seth Borenstein AP Science Writer / February 9, 2012 WASHINGTON—If scientists find microbes in a frigid lake two miles beneath the thick ice of Antarctica, it will illustrate once again that somehow life finds a way to survive in the strangest and ...
Lake Vostok drilling team claims breakthroughBBC News
Science Scanner: Russian Researchers Reach Ancient Antarctic LakeVoice of America (blog)
Russians Confirm They've Reached Two-Mile-Deep Antarctic Lake VostokTPM

all 1,064 news articles »


1st Prize at Science Conference: Free Trip to the Edge of Space
Space.com
The makers of a suborbital space plane have teamed up with the organizers of a science conference to offer attendees a chance to win a flight to the upper reaches of the atmosphere. But the deadline is coming fast. The 2012 Next Generation Suborbital ...

and more »


TIME

Class Notes: Science Fairs, Student Loans and More Education News
TIME
On Tuesday President Obama hosted the second White House Science Fair, complete with 30 exhibits, including a system to detect nuclear threats, a prosthetic hand, a high-speed marshmallow air cannon and portable disaster shelters. But the science fair ...

and more »


GigaOm

Study science and math to get ahead in the future of work, right?
GigaOm
9, 2012, 6:04am PT No Comments When you read accounts of the fierce competition for science and engineering grads, if you are a humanities or social science type (like me) you could be forgiven for slapping yourself on the forehead for forgoing the ...

and more »


Open Science Revolt Occupies Congress
Wired News
By David Dobbs The open-science revolt, catalyzed just a few weeks ago as a reaction to publisher Elsevier's backing of a clumsy bill introduced to the US .Congress, now has a champion in that Congress, Representative Mike Doyle, a Democrat of ...

and more »


County science fair back at SC4
Port Huron Times Herald
Noah Westrick, 10, of St. Clair, gets help from his mother, Renee, while setting up his project at the St. Clair County Science and Engineering Fair in 2009 before the judging at St. Clair County Community College. / Times Herald By CRYSTAL GARCIA ...

and more »


REFILE: Komen charity under microscope for funding, science
HealthNews
In recent years, however, it has cut by nearly half the proportion of fund-raising dollars it spends on grants to scientists working to understand the causes and develop effective new treatments for the disease. While the absolute dollar amount of ...

and more »


TIME

The Science of Animal Friendships: How Beasts Can Be BFFs
TIME
Wrong — and a growing field of science, which we report in this week's TIME cover story (available to subscribers here), is turning up all kinds of extraordinary proof. Take the pair of wild chimps known as Hare and Ellington, unrelated males who ...

and more »


PolicyMic

Santorum wins GOP vote in Minn.
Minnesota Daily
Griffin deputy campaign manager and political science sophomore Johnathon Walker conducts a count during a Democratic caucus Tuesday night in Coffman Union. By Kevin Burbach Rick Santorum won the Minnesota caucuses Tuesday night — a symbolic victory ...
Rick Santorum's Science Denial Will Kill Any Momentum the GOP Candidate HasPolicyMic

all 10,554 news articles »

Google News

home | site map | Xray Photography
© 2006