Science Information

Is Your Brain Really Necessary?


The reason for the apparently absurd question in the title is the remarkable research conducted at the University of Sheffield by neurology professor the late Dr. John Lorber.

When Sheffield's campus doctor was treating one of the mathematics students for a minor ailment, he noticed that the student's head was a little larger than normal. The doctor referred the student to professor Lorber for further examination.

The student in question was academically bright, had a reported IQ of 126 and was expected to graduate. When he was examined by CAT-scan, however, Lorber discovered that he had virtually no brain at all.

Instead of two hemispheres filling the cranial cavity, some 4.5 centimetres deep, the student had less than 1 millimetre of cerebral tissue covering the top of his spinal column. The student was suffering from hydrocephalus, the condition in which the cerebrospinal fluid, instead of circulating around the brain and entering the bloodstream, becomes dammed up inside.

Normally, the condition is fatal in the first months of childhood. Even where an individual survives he or she is usually seriously handicapped. Somehow, though, the Sheffield student had lived a perfectly normal life and went on to gain an honours degree in mathematics.

Professor Lorber (who was a member of the committee sitting to decide who should be awarded the Nobel Prize) identified several hundred people who have very small cerebral hemispheres but who appear to be normal intelligent individuals. Some of them he describes as having 'no detectable brain', yet they have scored up to 120 on IQ tests.

No-one knows how people with 'no detectable brain' are able to function at all, let alone to graduate in mathematics, but there are a couple theories. One idea is that there is such a high level of redundancy of function in the normal brain that what little remains is able to learn to deputise for the missing hemispheres.

Another, similar, suggestion is the old idea that we only use a small percentage of our brains anyway - perhaps as little as 10 per cent. The trouble with these ideas is that more recent research seems to contradict them. The functions of the brain have been mapped comprehensively and although there is some redundancy there is also a high degree of specialisation - the motor area and the visual cortex being highly specific for instance. Similarly, the idea that we 'only use 10 per cent of our brain' is a misunderstanding dating from research in the 1930s in which the functions of large areas of the cortex could not be determined and were dubbed 'silent', when in fact they are linked with important functions like speech and abstract thinking.

The other interesting thing about Lorber's findings is that they remind us of the mystery of memory. At first it was thought that memory would have some physical substrate in the brain, like the memory chips in a PC. But extensive investigation of the brain has turned up the surprising fact that memory is not located in any one area or in a specific substrate. As one eminent neurologist put it, 'memory is everywhere in the brain and nowhere.' But if the brain is not a mechanism for classifying and storing experiences and analysing them to enable us to live our lives then what on earth is the brain for? And where is the seat of human intelligence? Where is the mind?

Lorber's discovery is far from isolated. In researching my book 'Alternative Science' I found literally scores of such cases of scientific discoveries that are well-attested with strong direct laboratory evidence, and yet are ignored by conventional science. Many more such examples are also given on the Alternative Science Website.

Copyright Richard Milton 1994-2005

Richard Milton is a writer, journalist and broadcaster and author of five books including the controversial 'Alternative Science'. His Alternative Science website at http://www.alternativescience.com contains many extraordinary examples of hard scientific evidence for anomalous phenomena being ignored.


MORE RESOURCES:

Reuters Science News Summary
Chicago Tribune
Following is a summary of current science news briefs. Rare ``ring of fire'' solar eclipse dims skies KANARRAVILLE, Utah (Reuters) - The sun and moon aligned over the Earth in a rare astronomical event on Sunday - an annular eclipse that dimmed the ...

and more »


USA TODAY

The science behind Sunday's solar eclipse
Alaska Dispatch
Alaskans have a chance to catch a glimpse of a partial solar eclipse on Sunday afternoon. That's when the moon will pass in front of the Sun and cast a shadow across the home planet's surface on a trajectory that begins in Asia and crosses the ocean ...
Recommended: Eclipse Day! Get set for 'Ring of Fire'msnbc.com
Slightly overcast skies hamper eclipse viewingCalgary Herald
First solar eclipse of 2012 darkens western USAZFamily
Winnipeg Sun -Alameda Times-Star
all 2,989 news articles »


The Express Tribune

Fatty French Fries and Biomedical Breakthroughs: Intel's International Science ...
Knowledge Wharton Highschool
More than 1500 high school students considered the world's brightest young scientists took part in the Intel International Science & Engineering Fair (ISEF) 2012 on May 13-18. They shared ideas, showcased cutting-edge research and inventions and ...
Pakistani teens bag prize at international science fairThe Express Tribune
Cancer test scores $75000 science prize for teenUSA TODAY
Awards Honor Teens in Science CompetitionABC News
MarketWatch (press release)
all 221 news articles »


Boston Globe

The science behind sin
Boston Globe
Researchers gathered at the MIT Museum last month to describe work they've conducted relevant to the deadly seven, as part of the Cambridge Science Festival. The point of their assembly: to share some ways in which research can provide insight into ...



Plain Dealer

Students at Solon High, Middle schools win National Science Olympiad
Plain Dealer
By Donna J. Miller, Plain Dealer reporter View full sizeSpecial to The Plain DealerSolon High School and Solon Middle School students won first place in the National Science Olympiad Tournament for the second year in a row this weekend.
Top students from state compete in Science Olympiad national tourneyShelby Township Source Newspapers
Fort Collins teams win national events in science competitionThe Coloradoan
Fayetteville-Manlius HS places seventh in national Science OlympiadSyracuse.com
nwitimes.com -OCRegister -Post-Tribune
all 14 news articles »


Standards would immerse Arizona students in science
AZ Central.com
20, 2012 09:10 PM Arizona is one of 26 states leading a nationwide initiative aimed at improving science education by requiring a deeper understanding of key concepts and incorporating science and technology in all subjects. The first draft of the K-12 ...



Eureka! Science News

University of Nevada, Reno, scientists design indoor navigation system for blind
Eureka! Science News
University of Nevada, Reno computer science engineering team Kostas Bekris and Eelke Folmer presented their indoor navigation system for people with visual impairments at two national conferences in the past two weeks. The researchers explained how a ...

and more »


Univ. of Ala. hosts science education conference
WTVM
(AP) - The University of Alabama is hosting a national conference on science education. The Tuscaloosa News reports (http://bit.ly/JasU6O ) that the 2-day conference starts Monday at the Bryant Conference Center. Among the highlights will be a ...

and more »


Science Weekly podcast: X Factor for scientists – FameLab
The Guardian
A 2012 winner, a finalist and TV science presenter Alice Roberts discuss the importance of great science communication This week on Science Weekly we look at science communication and public engagement. FameLab is an international competition to find ...

and more »


Science Olympiad at Shanksville school
Daily American Online
Students in 4th and 5th grade at Shanksville-Stonycreek Elementary School recently participated in a Science Olympiad. The Olympiad was made possible through a grant from the Spectroscopy Society of Pittsburgh. McDonald's at Walmart donated straws that ...


Google News

home | site map | Xray Photography
© 2006